
Few legal matters feel as personal as deciding where your children will live and who will make decisions about their lives. A Holland child custody lawyer can help you understand how Michigan courts approach these questions and build a plan centered on your children.
At Buckman Tuinstra & Brown (BTB), our family law attorneys help West Michigan parents work through custody and parenting time issues with care and steady, practical guidance.
Custody questions come up in divorces, in cases between parents who were never married, and years after an order is entered when a family's life changes.
This page walks through the law Michigan judges apply, how cases move through the Ottawa County court, and what parents can do to prepare.
No outcome is guaranteed in any custody case, but understanding the standard gives you a clearer starting point, so call Buckman Tuinstra & Brown at (616) 394-4276 for a free consultation.
How Our Family Law Team Approaches Custody in Holland
Every custody case turns on the children at its center, so we start by learning about your kids, their routines, and what each parent contributes. From there, we help you decide where cooperation is realistic and where firmer advocacy is needed.
Building a Parenting Plan That Works

When parents can communicate, a detailed agreement usually serves children better than a decision imposed by a judge. We help parents negotiate practical terms on schedules, holidays, school decisions, and exchanges, and we draft them clearly enough to prevent future disputes. Anne L. Tuinstra, a BTB partner who primarily practices family law, is an experienced mediator as well as a litigator.
When Agreement Is Not Possible
Some cases require a judge to decide. In those situations, we focus on the evidence Michigan courts actually weigh, such as school records, daily caregiving history, and each parent's ability to support the child's relationship with the other parent.
Preparing that evidence early often makes the difference between a persuasive case and a frustrating one.
Legal Custody vs. Physical Custody: The Four Arrangements
Michigan separates custody into two parts: legal custody, which covers who makes major decisions, and physical custody, which covers where the child lives.
Each part can be joint or sole, which creates four combinations that are easy to confuse. The table below shows how they differ.
| Type | What It Controls | What It Looks Like Day to Day |
|---|---|---|
| Joint legal custody | Both parents share important decisions, such as education, non-emergency health care, and religious upbringing | Parents consult each other before major choices; each handles routine matters during their own time |
| Sole legal custody | One parent makes important decisions alone | Often ordered when parents cannot cooperate on decisions |
| Joint physical custody | The child lives alternately with each parent for specific periods | Schedules vary widely and do not have to be an exact 50/50 split |
| Sole (primary) physical custody | The child lives mainly with one parent | The other parent usually receives parenting time |
Under Michigan's Child Custody Act of 1970, a court must consider joint custody when either parent asks for it and must explain its reasons on the record.
When parents agree to joint custody, the court awards it unless clear and convincing evidence shows it is not in the child's best interests.
How Is Custody Decided in Michigan? The Best Interest Factors
Every Michigan custody decision between parents is governed by the best interests of the child, defined in Michigan Compiled Laws (MCL) section 722.23 as the sum of twelve factors.
Judges evaluate each factor and explain how it applies, so these factors shape both trials and settlement talks:
- Love, affection, and emotional ties: the bond between each parent and the child.
- Guidance and upbringing: each parent's capacity and willingness to give love and guidance and to continue the child's education and religion, if any.
- Material needs: each parent's capacity to provide food, clothing, medical care, and other necessities.
- Stability: how long the child has lived in a stable, satisfactory environment, and the value of keeping that continuity.
- Permanence of the home: whether each proposed custodial home is likely to stay stable as a family unit.
- Moral fitness: conduct that bears on a parent's ability to raise the child.
- Mental and physical health: each parent's health as it affects parenting.
- The child's record: how the child is doing at home, in school, and in the community.
- The child's reasonable preference: considered when the court finds the child old enough to express one.
- Supporting the other relationship: each parent's willingness to encourage a close relationship between the child and the other parent. Reasonable steps to protect a child or parent from domestic violence or sexual assault cannot count against a parent here.
- Domestic violence: whether or not it was directed at or witnessed by the child.
- Any other relevant factor: anything else the court finds important in the particular case.
No single factor automatically decides a case, and judges are not required to weigh them equally. For joint custody, the court also considers whether the parents can cooperate and generally agree on important decisions.
How Does the Established Custodial Environment Affect the Burden of Proof?
Before weighing the best interest factors, a Michigan court asks whether the child has an established custodial environment with one or both parents. That answer determines how much proof a parent needs to change the child's situation.

What Creates an Established Custodial Environment
Under MCL 722.27, a custodial environment is established when, over an appreciable time, the child naturally looks to the custodian for guidance, discipline, the necessities of life, and parental comfort.
Courts also consider the child's age, the physical environment, and how permanent the relationship is expected to be. A child can have an established custodial environment with both parents at once.
Why It Matters
A court cannot enter an order that changes an established custodial environment unless clear and convincing evidence shows the change is in the child's best interests. That is a demanding standard, and it often decides contested cases.
When no established custodial environment exists, Michigan courts generally apply the lower preponderance of the evidence standard.
Parenting Time Is Separate From Custody
Parenting time is the schedule a parent spends with the child, and it is decided separately from custody labels.
Michigan law presumes a child benefits from a strong relationship with both parents, and parenting time is granted in a frequency, duration, and type meant to promote that relationship.
Either parent can ask the court to set parenting time in specific terms rather than a general "reasonable" schedule.
Under MCL 722.27a, courts may consider several factors when setting the schedule, including:
- Special circumstances or needs of the child
- Whether the child is a nursing infant
- A reasonable likelihood of abuse or neglect of the child, or abuse of a parent, during parenting time
- The burden travel places on the child
- Whether a parent is likely to follow the order, and whether a parent has often failed to use their time
- Any threatened or actual attempt to hide the child from the other parent
When parents agree on parenting time terms, the court generally adopts them unless clear and convincing evidence shows they are not in the child's best interests. Orders can also include practical conditions, such as who handles transportation and when exchanges happen.
How Can You Change an Existing Custody Order?
Children grow, parents move, and schedules that worked at age four may not work at age twelve. Michigan allows custody orders to be revisited, but not simply because a parent would prefer a different arrangement.
The Threshold: Proper Cause or Change of Circumstances

A court can modify a custody order only for proper cause shown or because of a change of circumstances.
Michigan appellate courts, including in Vodvarka v Grasmeyer, have interpreted this to require significant developments that could affect the child's well-being, not ordinary life changes.
If a parent clears that threshold, the court then applies the best interest factors and the burden of proof tied to the child's custodial environment.
Preparing a Modification Request
Strong modification cases rest on specific, documented changes, such as a new work schedule, a move, school problems, or safety concerns. Keeping a written record of exchanges, missed parenting time, and communication helps a judge see the change clearly.
Moving With Your Child: Michigan's 100-Mile Rule
When custody is governed by a court order, MCL 722.31 generally prevents a parent from moving the child's legal residence more than 100 miles from where it was when the case began.
The rule does not apply if the other parent consents, if one parent has sole legal custody, if the parents already lived more than 100 miles apart when the case started, or if the move brings the two homes closer together. Otherwise, a parent needs court permission.
In deciding whether to allow the move, the court keeps the child as its primary focus and considers:
- Whether the move can improve quality of life for both the child and the relocating parent
- How each parent has used their parenting time, and whether the move is meant to frustrate the other parent's time
- Whether a revised schedule can preserve the child's relationship with each parent, and whether both parents will likely follow it
- Whether the parent opposing the move is motivated by a financial advantage related to support
- Domestic violence, whether or not directed at or witnessed by the child
A parent who needs to reach a safe location because of domestic violence may move with the child before the court rules. If the move would also change the child's established custodial environment, the court may need to address custody as well.
Custody Cases in Ottawa County and the Friend of the Court
For most Holland families, custody matters are heard by the family division of Ottawa County's 20th Circuit Court. Families living in the Allegan County portion of the Holland area file in the Allegan County circuit court instead.

What the Friend of the Court Does in Custody Matters
The Friend of the Court (FOC) is part of the circuit court's family division, and it plays a significant role when children are involved.
Depending on the case, the FOC may investigate custody or parenting time disputes and make recommendations to the judge, offer dispute resolution services, and help enforce parenting time orders when one parent does not follow them.
FOC recommendations carry weight, so parents should take every FOC meeting and request for information seriously.
What to Expect Procedurally
After the first filing, Ottawa County requires most documents to be filed electronically through the MiFILE system. Contested custody cases can involve FOC interviews, referee or judge hearings, and sometimes the appointment of a guardian ad litem or lawyer for the child.
Having an attorney who knows the local process helps you anticipate each step instead of reacting to it.
FAQs for Holland Child Custody Cases
At what age can a child choose which parent to live with in Michigan?
Michigan has no set age at which a child decides custody. A Michigan court considers a child's reasonable preference when it finds the child old enough to express one, but that preference is only one of twelve best interest factors and does not control the outcome.
Do Michigan courts favor mothers in custody cases?
No. Michigan custody law does not give either parent a preference based on gender. Judges decide custody by applying the statutory best interest factors to each parent's actual relationship with and care for the child.
Can unmarried parents get custody orders in Michigan?
Yes. Parents who were never married can ask a Michigan circuit court to decide custody, parenting time, and support. For a father, legal parentage typically must be established first, for example through an acknowledgment of parentage or a court order.
Does joint custody mean no child support in Michigan?
No. Under Michigan law, joint custody does not eliminate child support. Support is still calculated under the Michigan Child Support Formula, which accounts for each parent's income and the number of overnights the child spends with each parent.
What can I do if the other parent ignores our custody or parenting time order in Michigan?
A parent in Michigan can report the violation to the Friend of the Court, which can take enforcement steps, or file a motion with the court. Depending on the circumstances, a judge may order makeup parenting time, modify the order, or hold the violating parent in contempt.

Speak With a Holland Child Custody Lawyer
If you are facing a custody decision, preparing early and understanding the standard the court will apply can make the process less stressful for you and your children.
Buckman Tuinstra & Brown offers free consultations to help Holland-area parents understand their options. Every family is different, and results depend on the specific facts of each case.
Call Buckman Tuinstra & Brown at (616) 394-4276 or reach us through our online contact form to schedule a free consultation at our office at 272 E 8th St in downtown Holland.
The information on this page is general and is not legal advice. Contacting our firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.