Holland traumatic brain injury lawyers know that a serious brain injury does not always show up on a CT scan or MRI.
Many people are sent home from the emergency room with "normal" imaging results, only to develop headaches, memory loss, mood changes, and trouble concentrating days or weeks later.
Insurance companies often use that gap between normal test results and real-life symptoms to argue that the injury is minor or not related to the accident. Without clear medical records, valid brain injury claims are often undervalued or denied.
At Buckman Tuinstra & Brown, our Holland traumatic brain injury attorneys build claims using neuropsychological testing, treatment records, and evidence that shows how the injury affects daily life.
This approach helps connect the medical evidence to the real impact on your ability to work, think, and function. Call (616) 394-4276 to have an attorney review your medical records and evaluate your brain injury claim.
Why TBI Claims Require a Different Kind of Legal Preparation
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) litigation turns on medical proof, not just witness testimony or police reports.
The person with a brain injury may appear physically healthy while struggling with cognitive, emotional, and behavioral symptoms that standard medical imaging does not capture.
An attorney who lacks experience reading neuropsychological evaluations and coordinating with treating neurologists may undervalue or mishandle the claim.
How Our Holland Attorneys Build TBI Cases

Jeffrey Buckman has litigated injury cases involving brain trauma in Michigan state and federal courts, including claims where initial hospital imaging appeared normal but later neuropsychological testing revealed lasting cognitive deficits.
Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is different.
We coordinate directly with your neurologist, neuropsychologist, and rehabilitation team to build a medical record that documents what the insurance company's hired consultant is paid to minimize.
Our estate planning attorneys also step in when a TBI creates the need for a guardianship, a conservatorship, or a special needs trust to protect settlement proceeds and government benefit eligibility.
Adam Bancroft, who handles probate litigation across Ottawa and surrounding counties, manages those proceedings in coordination with the injury claim.
That medical-legal coordination runs through a single office on 8th Street in downtown Holland. Call (616) 394-4276 to have us review your records and give you a clear picture of your claim.
How Are Brain Injuries Classified by Severity?
Medical professionals classify traumatic brain injuries using the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS), a scoring system that measures consciousness based on eye, verbal, and motor responses. The GCS score assigned shortly after the injury determines the initial severity classification.
TBI Severity Levels
| Classification | GCS Score | Typical Indicators |
|---|---|---|
| Mild TBI (concussion) | 13 to 15 | Brief or no loss of consciousness, confusion, headache, short-term memory difficulty |
| Moderate TBI | 9 to 12 | Loss of consciousness lasting 30 minutes to 24 hours, abnormal brain imaging, prolonged confusion |
| Severe TBI | 3 to 8 | Extended loss of consciousness, significant brain bleeding or swelling, coma |
The word "mild" in the medical classification misleads many people. A mild TBI may still produce months or years of cognitive difficulty, personality changes, and inability to work.
Insurance adjusters use the "mild" label to minimize claims, even when the injured person's daily functioning tells a completely different story.
Your attorney and your neuropsychologist must work together to reframe that label with functional evidence.
What Symptoms Make a TBI Hard to Prove in Court?

Many TBI symptoms are subjective, meaning they rely on the injured person's self-reporting rather than a blood test or an X-ray. Insurance defense attorneys target that subjectivity aggressively, and they hire their own medical consultants to challenge the diagnosis.
Symptoms That Insurers Frequently Dispute
The following TBI symptoms are common in moderate and mild brain injury cases but difficult to capture on standard medical imaging:
- Persistent headaches and sensitivity to light or noise
- Short-term memory loss and trouble concentrating
- Irritability, mood swings, anxiety, or depression that emerged after the injury
- Difficulty finding words, following conversations, or completing routine tasks
- Sleep disruption, fatigue, and reduced tolerance for mental effort
A neuropsychological evaluation, which is a series of structured cognitive tests administered by a neuropsychologist, provides the objective measurement that subjective symptom reports alone do not.
The evaluation generates scored data on memory, processing speed, attention, language, and executive function. That data becomes the backbone of the TBI claim.
What Causes Traumatic Brain Injuries in Holland and West Michigan?
Motor vehicle collisions on the I-196 and US-31 corridors are among the most common causes of TBI in Ottawa County. Holland's manufacturing and construction industries also contribute, particularly in cases involving falls from height, struck-by incidents, and machinery accidents.
Common Causes of TBI Claims We See in Ottawa County
Our attorneys have represented brain injury victims across a range of accident types in West Michigan:
- Car, truck, and motorcycle collisions, including rear-end impacts that cause the brain to strike the inside of the skull
- Falls from ladders, scaffolding, or elevated work platforms at construction and industrial sites
- Slip and fall accidents on commercial property, particularly impacts where the head strikes a hard surface
- Bicycle and pedestrian accidents involving motor vehicles
- Recreational and sports-related impacts, including concussions that go undiagnosed or untreated
The cause of the TBI shapes both the liability theory and the available insurance coverage. A motor vehicle brain injury involves Michigan's no-fault PIP system alongside a potential third-party claim.
A workplace TBI may involve both a workers' compensation claim and a third-party negligence claim against a non-employer. A Holland brain injury attorney identifies every available source of recovery based on how the injury occurred.
What Damages Are Specific to a Brain Injury Claim?
Brain injury compensation in Michigan covers both the measurable financial losses and the personal toll of living with impaired cognition, altered personality, and reduced independence.

TBI damages differ from other personal injury claims because the effects often worsen over time rather than improving.
Financial and Personal Losses in a TBI Case
A brain injury claim in Michigan may include the following categories of compensation:
- Past and projected neurological care, including specialist visits, imaging, medications, and cognitive rehabilitation
- Neuropsychological evaluations and ongoing mental health treatment
- Lost wages and diminished earning capacity when cognitive deficits prevent returning to prior employment
- Attendant care and daily living assistance when the TBI affects the person's ability to manage household tasks, finances, or self-care
- Pain, emotional distress, loss of relationships, and reduced ability to participate in family and community life
Michigan's comparative fault rule under MCL 600.2959 applies to TBI claims the same way it applies to any negligence case. Your recovery is reduced by your share of fault, and noneconomic damages are barred if fault exceeds 50%.
For motor vehicle TBI claims, the injured person must also meet the serious impairment of body function threshold under MCL 500.3135 to recover pain and suffering from the at-fault driver.
Why Do Insurance Companies Challenge Brain Injury Diagnoses?
Insurance carriers dispute TBI claims more aggressively than most other injury types because the medical evidence is easier to attack.
A broken bone shows up on an X-ray. A torn ligament appears on an MRI. A mild or moderate brain injury may produce no visible finding on a CT or standard MRI, even when the injured person's cognitive function has declined significantly.
Tactics Insurers Use Against TBI Claimants
Defense teams in brain injury cases commonly rely on the following strategies:
- Pointing to normal CT or MRI results as evidence that no brain injury occurred
- Attributing cognitive symptoms to preexisting conditions like depression, ADHD, or aging
- Hiring a neuropsychologist to re-evaluate the injured person and produce a competing report
- Arguing that the "mild" TBI classification means the symptoms are temporary and minor
- Claiming the injured person's reported difficulties are exaggerated or inconsistent with daily activities
Countering these attacks requires a neuropsychological evaluation performed early, a clear treatment timeline that links symptoms to the accident, and testimony from treating physicians who have monitored the injured person over time.
Your attorney coordinates that evidence package before the insurance company's hired consultant has a chance to set the narrative.
FAQs for Holland Traumatic Brain Injury Lawyers
Do I have a brain injury claim if my CT scan came back normal?
Yes, you may still have a valid TBI claim even with a normal CT scan. Standard CT imaging detects bleeding and fractures but often misses diffuse axonal injury, which is microscopic damage to brain cell connections caused by rotational force.
A neuropsychological evaluation measures cognitive function directly and may reveal deficits that imaging alone does not capture.
What is the filing deadline for a brain injury lawsuit in Michigan?
Michigan's statute of limitations for most brain injury claims is three years from the date of injury under MCL 600.5805. For motor vehicle TBI cases, no-fault PIP benefits must be filed within one year.
Exceptions may apply in cases involving minors or government entities. An attorney reviews which deadlines apply to your specific situation.
Start Building Your Holland Traumatic Brain Injury Claim
The gap between how a brain injury looks on paper and how it affects daily life is exactly where insurance companies save money.
Closing that gap requires neuropsychological evidence, coordinated medical records, and an attorney who understands how to present cognitive deficits to a jury in Ottawa County.
Buckman Tuinstra & Brown reviews brain injury claims from our office in downtown Holland. Call (616) 394-4276 and let us look at the medical records. We tell you what the claim looks like and what steps make sense from here.