Holland Premises Liability Lawyers

Michigan property owners lost a major legal defense in 2023, giving many injury victims who were previously turned away a renewed path to compensation. Under current Michigan law, the fact that a hazard was visible no longer automatically defeats a premises liability claim.

After Kandil-Elsayed, whether a danger was open and obvious typically affects breach and comparative fault, not whether the property owner owed the injured person a duty.

The Holland premises liability lawyers at Buckman Tuinstra & Brown represent people injured by unsafe property conditions in stores, parking lots, rental units, restaurants, and private homes across Ottawa County and the Lakeshore.

If a property hazard in Holland or West Michigan caused your injury, call (616) 394-4276 to find out where your claim stands under current Michigan law.

Request a Free Consultation

Who Represents Property Injury Victims in Holland, MI?

Jeffrey W. Buckman, Personal Injury Lawyer in Holland, MI

Buckman Tuinstra & Brown handles premises liability cases from its 8th Street office in downtown Holland. The firm moves quickly to preserve physical evidence, maintenance records, and surveillance footage before hazards are repaired or video is overwritten.

Why Litigation Readiness Matters

Property injury claims often face early, low settlement offers from insurers. Trial attorney Jeffrey Buckman prepares cases for court from the start, strengthening negotiating leverage.

Adam Bancroft adds experience in property-related litigation across Ottawa, Allegan, and Kalamazoo counties, with in-house real estate attorneys available for lease, code, or landlord-tenant issues.

There is no charge for the initial conversation about your property injury. We explain all fee terms in writing before any representation begins. Call (616) 394-4276.

What Changed About Michigan Premises Liability Law?

Jeffrey W Buckman Martindale-Hubbell 2026 badge

In 2023, the Michigan Supreme Court changed the open and obvious rule in Kandil-Elsayed v. F & E Oil, Inc., 512 Mich 95. The Court held that the open and obvious nature of a hazard no longer decides whether a property owner owed a duty.

Before this ruling, property owners often used this rule to get injury cases dismissed. They argued that hazards like icy sidewalks or broken steps were easy to see, so the injured person should have noticed them.

As a result, many cases were thrown out before a jury could hear them.

How the Ruling Affects Your Claim

That defense no longer eliminates the property owner's duty of care. Instead, courts now treat the obviousness of a hazard as one factor in comparative fault, meaning a jury decides how to split responsibility between you and the property owner.

Michigan's modified comparative fault rule under MCL 600.2959 still reduces your recovery by your percentage of fault and bars noneconomic damages if your fault exceeds 50%.

The practical result is that premises liability cases in Michigan now survive early dismissal more often and reach the discovery and trial stages where evidence and preparation matter most.

How Does Michigan Determine What a Property Owner Owes You?

The duty of care a Michigan property owner owes depends on why you were on the property. Michigan law recognizes three categories of visitors, and each one triggers a different level of legal responsibility.

Visitor Status and Duty of Care in Michigan

Visitor StatusDefinitionProperty Owner's Duty
InviteeA person on the property for a commercial purpose, such as a customer in a storeInspect the property for hazards, repair or warn of dangerous conditions, and maintain reasonably safe premises
LicenseeA social guest on the property with the owner's permissionWarn of known hazards that the guest is unlikely to discover on their own
TrespasserA person on the property without permissionGenerally, no duty of care beyond refraining from intentional harm (special rules apply to children under the attractive nuisance doctrine)

Your visitor status at the moment of injury shapes the entire case. A customer who slips in a Holland grocery store aisle has a stronger claim than someone who wanders onto private property without permission, because the store owes an active duty to inspect and maintain.

An attorney reviews the facts of your visit and identifies which classification applies.

What Does a Premises Liability Claim Require in Michigan?

A Michigan premises liability claim requires proof of four elements: duty, breach, causation, and damages. Each element must be established by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning it is more likely true than not.

The Four Elements Broken Down

Every successful property injury claim in Michigan rests on these components:

  • The property owner owed you a duty of care based on your visitor status
  • The owner breached that duty by failing to inspect, repair, or warn of a dangerous condition
  • The breach directly caused your injury
  • You suffered actual damages, such as medical expenses, lost income, or pain

Property owners and their insurers often focus on the breach element, arguing that the condition existed for too short a time to discover or that they took reasonable steps.

Photographs, maintenance logs, surveillance footage, and witness testimony all play a role in proving or disproving that argument.

Where Do Property Injuries Happen Most Often in West Michigan?

Slip and fall injuries are the most recognized type of premises liability case, but property hazard claims across Ottawa County extend well beyond wet floors.

Holland's mix of older commercial buildings, seasonal freeze-thaw cycles, and heavy pedestrian traffic during Tulip Time and summer tourism creates a pattern of recurring property hazards.

Hazards That Drive Claims in Holland and Ottawa County

Local property conditions in West Michigan contribute to a distinct set of injury risks throughout the year:

  • Uncleared ice and compacted snow on sidewalks, parking lots, and building entrances during months of sub-freezing weather
  • Broken or uneven flooring, staircases, and handrails inside aging commercial buildings and rental units along 8th Street and throughout downtown
  • Poor lighting in parking structures, apartment hallways, and restaurant stairwells
  • Merchandise or debris left in store aisles during high-traffic retail periods
  • Defective or missing guardrails on balconies, decks, and elevated walkways at lakefront properties

A Holland premises liability attorney can identify which statute or common-law rule applies to your specific situation.

Why Evidence Disappears Fast in Property Injury Cases

Conditions at the injury site can change quickly. Floors get mopped, railings get repaired, and snow melts or refreezes. Within hours, the hazard that caused your fall may look different, and security footage is often overwritten within 30 to 90 days.

What Happens in the First Week of a Property Injury Claim

Our attorneys send spoliation letters, which are formal written demands requiring the property owner and any third-party maintenance companies to preserve relevant records, footage, and physical evidence.

We also photograph the scene, identify witnesses, pull weather data for ice and snow cases, and request maintenance and inspection logs.

The strength of a premises claim often depends on what happens in the first seven to ten days after the injury. Waiting weeks or months to contact an attorney gives the other side time to clean up, repair, and overwrite the evidence your case depends on.

FAQs for Holland Premises Liability Lawyers

Does the property owner have to know about the hazard before I have a claim?

It depends on your visitor status. For invitees (customers and business visitors), the property owner has a duty to inspect the property and discover hazards through reasonable care.

The owner does not need actual knowledge of the specific condition if a reasonable inspection would have revealed it. For licensees (social guests), the owner must only warn of hazards the owner already knew about.

How long do I have to file a premises liability claim in Michigan?

Michigan's statute of limitations for most premises liability claims is three years from the date of injury under MCL 600.5805. Shorter notice deadlines may apply if the property is owned or maintained by a government entity.

Contacting an attorney soon after the injury protects both your filing rights and the physical evidence at the property.

Talk to a Holland Premises Liability Lawyer About Your Property Injury

The legal ground shifted in Michigan after the 2023 Kandil-Elsayed ruling, and property injury claims that once failed at the courthouse door now reach juries.

If you were hurt on someone else's property in Holland, Zeeland, Grand Haven, or anywhere in Ottawa County, the analysis of your case looks different today than it did just a few years ago.

Buckman Tuinstra & Brown reviews property injury claims from our office on 8th Street in downtown Holland. Call (616) 394-4276 to find out whether the current state of Michigan premises liability law supports your claim.

Request a Free Consultation